Who Gets Sick in Space? Inspiration4 May Offer More Clues.
Commercial spaceflight brings a more diverse cross section of humanity beyond Earth, helping medical researchers collect data.,
Who Gets Sick in Space? Orbital Tourists May Offer Better Clues.
Commercial spaceflight brings a more diverse cross section of humanity beyond Earth, helping medical researchers collect data.
Hayley Arceneaux, Inspiration4’s medical officer, during a training flight. She is younger than most astronauts, a cancer survivor and the first person with a prosthetic device to visit space.Credit…John Kraus/Inspiration4
Doctors have poked and prodded NASA astronauts for years, and the astronauts, as government employees, have largely acceded to their roles as test animals in studying how an alien environment — outer space — affects the human body.
But professional astronauts have historically been a small slice of humanity. Initially, they were chosen from the ranks of military test pilots who were white, physically fit men. Later, as NASA broadened its criteria, it still chose only astronauts who passed their physical thresholds.
But that could be changing as private spaceflight opens space to a more diverse cross section of humanity.
For scientists, the change will create a bonanza of new data on how the human body adapts to space.
The Inspiration4 mission, which launched on Wednesday, shows how medical researchers can benefit from the new commercial space travel. The crew of four, none of whom is a professional astronaut, will spend a fair amount of time in orbit helping to advance medical research.
One of the passengers, Hayley Arceneaux, exemplifies those possibilities. At 29, she is younger than most space travelers, a cancer survivor and will be the first person in space with a prosthesis — metal rods that were implanted after a tumor was removed from her left leg.
“We’re going to learn some things that are very fundamental,” said Dorit Donoviel, executive director of the Translational Research Institute for Space Health, or TRISH, at the Baylor College of Medicine in Houston, which is coordinating research during the Inspiration4 flight.
Research to date has revealed that fluids shift upward in the body in the absence of gravity — swollen heads, shrunken legs. The lack of gravity also weakens bones. Not only does radiation in space slam into DNA creating mutations, but the unusual conditions of weightlessness cause some genes to turn on and others to turn off. The biological repercussions of these alterations are not yet understood.
The crew aboard Inspiration4 will take 10 tests originally designed to gauge the mental performance of NASA astronauts each day. The tests take about 20 minutes to complete.
“It needed to be brief, because astronauts kind of hate doing these things,” said Dr. Mathias Basner, a professor of psychiatry at the University of Pennsylvania who is the lead investigator for that experiment.
But in a dangerous environment like space, small errors can lead to catastrophe.
“So we need our astronauts to perform at their best all the time,” Dr. Basner said. “Now, the problem is that humans are particularly bad at self-assessing their performance capability, especially in chronic exposure situations. If you sit in the same environment all the time, you think you’ll be fine, but you’re actually not.”
Wednesday’s launch from Cape Canaveral in Florida. The crew will perform several tests, from those designed to gauge mental performance and visual acuity, to trying out ultrasound devices that track how water shifts in their bodies in low gravity.Credit…Chandan Khanna/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images
One test is simply a square that appears on a screen, and one has to tap on it. The square changes position and progressively becomes smaller. That measures the reaction speed and eye-hand coordination.
Another measures what is known as psychomotor vigilance. First, the subject stares at a box on the screen. A stopwatch suddenly pops up within the box, counting the milliseconds until the subject presses a button. “Which is extremely sensitive to sleep deprivation,” Dr. Basner said.
Yet another test gauges a person’s ability to identify emotions in other people.
The test displays 20 faces showing a variety of emotions — happy, sad, angry, fearful or expressing no emotion. In a so-called bed rest study — lying down for extended periods of time mimics many of the physical effects of weightlessness in space — subjects were able to still correctly identify most of the emotions. But they took longer to identify them, and their responses skewed to more negative expressions.
Mark J. Shelhamer, a professor at Johns Hopkins Medicine, is gathering data on how spaceflight affects the vestibular system — the parts of the human body, particularly the inner ear, that maintain balance.
His research consists of two parts, to be conducted before launch and after the return to Earth. One will measure the crew members’ postures. “It’s just what it sounds like,” Dr. Shelhamer said. “It’s the ability to stand up. And the ability to stand up is not only based on muscle strength, but it’s based on coordination.”
The Inspiration4 crew members will hold a Windows tablet to their chests, put their feet together and close their eyes. Accelerators in the tablet will measure how much they sway as they stand.
“That’s not so hard to do on Earth,” Dr. Shelhamer said. “But it can be challenging after having spent some time in space.”
Dr. Shelhamer has also devised a test using the tablet to study whether weightlessness causes eyes to become misaligned. That could give hints of how the brain might become confused, disrupting the sense of balance.
What researchers want to learn is how to predict who becomes sick in space. Surprisingly, there is no correlation between who experiences motion sickness on Earth — on a boat rocking back and forth, during a long car trip, even short episodes of floating during parabolic plane flights — and those who become sick in orbit.
From left, Christopher Sembroski, Sian Proctor, Jared Isaacman and Ms. Arceneaux in the crew capsule, two minutes before launch.Credit…SpaceX, via Agence France-Presse — Getty Images
“We don’t understand this at all,” Dr. Shelhamer said. “It’s an embarrassment, because we would like to think that it’s the same fundamental mechanisms — the fact that the different sensory systems don’t match up.”
TRISH, the organization Dr. Donoviel leads, has built a database to store the study results that not only protects the privacy of private space travelers in accordance with the requirements of HIPAA, the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act, but will also allow researchers to compare data from different studies for one individual.
For instance, Dr. Shelhamer might want to know whether an individual whose ability to stand straight without swaying declined after a trip to space also encountered cognitive slowdowns while taking Dr. Basner’s tests in space. That is often not possible with how NASA reports data collected on its astronauts, he said.
In addition, the Inspiration4 crew members are wearing Apple Watches that will measure their heart beats and oxygen levels. They will also test out ultrasound devices that can track how water in their bodies shifts upward while they float in orbit. That could help solve the puzzle of the squashing of eyeballs and resulting shift in vision experienced by some astronauts.
The research does depend on how well the Inspiration4 crew feels during their trip. Because there is no way to predict who gets sick in space, it is possible that they all will and then they may not be able to do much research during the three-day trip.
“My worry is that they’re not going to enjoy their time in space,” Dr. Donoviel said. “They may not be able to carry out the experiments that we are sending up. So that is a risk that I’m taking.”